Monday, July 18, 2011

PA Bar Promotes "Wills for Heroes" Further

In an emailed member newsletter received July 18, 2011, the Pennsylvania Bar Association continues its support and promotion of a "Wills for Heroes" program, as pioneered in 2007-08 by the American Bar Association, through a specialized statewide program in the Commonwealth conducted by the PBA's Young Lawyers Division:
Invitation to Volunteer for PBA YLD-supported 'Wills for Heroes' Programs
The PBA Young Lawyers Division is a proud co-sponsor of the "Wills for Heroes" program in Pennsylvania. Through the support of volunteer lawyers and paralegals, the program provides free wills and other estate planning documents for police, firefighters and emergency medical personnel who risk their lives every day for the safety of their fellow citizens.
Consider becoming a "Wills for Heroes" volunteer. Click here for more information, including a list of upcoming summer and fall events across the state. Click here for additional details for lawyer volunteers.
I've noted the development of such programs in Pennsylvania over the years. See: "Wills for Heroes" Workshops Multiply in PA & DE (08/03/10); PBA's Young Lawyers Sponsor "Wills for Heroes" (05/06/09); and Firefighters, First Responders, and Free Wills (05/15/08). The Program appears healthy and expansive.

Pennsylvania's program is conducted in conjunction with the Wills for Heroes Foundation. It is operated on a county basis through local bar associations. Click here for a list of county coordinators. For more information, you may send an email message to the PBA's Young Lawyers Division, the Pennsylvania program Director Dan McKenna, or the Pennsylvania program Co-Chair/Director Lisa Shearman.

PBA members can sign up online here to join a thriving movement with worthy objectives.

Thursday, June 23, 2011

One Paper Size Fits All Pa Inheritance Tax Returns

Effective April 1, 2011 any REV-1500 (PA Resident Inheritance Tax Return), including attachments, submitted to the Pennsylvania Inheritance Tax Division in a format size other than 8½ x 11 will be rejected by the Department of Revenue, which will equate to a non-filing.

Pursuant to a Notice entitled REV-1500 Formatting Limitations to 8½” X 11”  issued by the Pennsylvania Department of Revenue, Inheritance Tax Division, and referenced by the Registers of Wills in at least two Pennsylvania Counties -- Center County (Inheritance Tax Return Formatting Limitation to 8 1/2" X 11") and Chester County (Inheritance Tax Returns REV 1500 Required Formatting) -- returns not filed on standard letter-sized (8½” X 11”) paper will be rejected.

Rejection (read, "non-filing") will occur because such a filing would "not conform" to the Pennsylvania Inheritance and Estate Tax Act of 1991, 72 P.S. §9136, and the Department's requirements.  That Section provides:
§ 9136.  Returns.  
(a) The following persons shall make a return: * * *
(c) Any person required to file a return under subsection (a) shall promptly file a
supplemental return with respect to additional assets and transfers which come to his knowledge after the original return has been filed. * * *
(e) The returns required by subsections (a) and (c) shall be made in the form prescribed by the department.
The Notice explains why the new limitation will be enforced.
Historically, the Department has manually reduced the size of any 8½” x 14” REV-1500 by coping them onto 8½” x 11” paper.  The copies do not image correctly and the loss of division personnel has required us to input this new procedure.
The REV-1500 is in an official format of 8½” x 11”. The Department will return the forms to the local Register of Wills’ office and note on the inheritance tax system that the forms were returned to the Register’s office as the form did not fit the standard format. * * *
However, there was a phase-in period for the change, which began on April 1, 2011, but will expire on June 30, 2011.
The Department has recommend to the Register of Wills’ office personnel to immediately inform estate return preparers when they bring a REV-1500 to their office printed on any format that is not 8½” x 11” that the Register’s office will reject the REV-1500 to be forwarded to the Department for processing and advise the preparer of the correct procedures.
As a representative of the PA Department of Revenue, Inheritance Tax Division, the county Register of Wills office does have the authority to refuse any form that does not qualify as an accepted form for processing under the above noted section.

From April 1, 2011 [until] June 30, 2011, the Department will inform the estate representative that the forms were sent back to the Register’s offices as a result of incorrect formatting. The estate representative will be required to deliver to the Register a revised REV-1500 formatted correctly and pay any additional filing fee as required.

After June 30, 2011, the Department will discontinue informing the estate representative of their error.
The effort to standardize paper sizes has a long history.  In the legal world, paper sizes have been determined as much by the two standard filing cabinet sizes as anything else.  But now technology, with its scanning processes and computer monitor viewing, drives paper standardization.  Aberrant paper sizes will not be accommodated any longer, due to additional processing costs incurred to fit the systems.

So, when it comes to the filing of Inheritance Tax Returns in Pennsylvania after June 30, 2011, one size shall fit all.

Update: 11/02/11:

For those seeking an overview of, or online resources about, Pennsylvania Inheritance and Estate Taxes, see: PA EE&F Law Blog posting PA Inheritance Tax Summarized (11/02/11).

Thursday, June 16, 2011

Proposed PA Adoption Rule Changes

On Saturday, June 11, 2011, in the Pennsylvania Bulletin, Volume 41, No. 24, publication appeared regarding proposed and renumbered Orphans' Court Rules governing Adoptions under Rule 15.  This is a major revision and update of that Rule and its sub-rules (15.1 - 15.16).

The proposed rule changes would accomplish two general objectives:  1) Amend the statewide adoption rules after the enactment of the Open Adoption Act in the Commonwealth, which became effective on April 25, 2011, and 2) generally update the adoption rules for clarity in existing practice.  The first objective reflects a substantive change in adoption law, while the second objective reflects clarifications.

The Open Adoption Law was approved by the Legislature as Senate Bill 1360, Printer's Number 2188, on October 27, 2010.  Governor Edward G. Rendell signed it into law as Act 101 of 2010.  The amendments to the Adoption Act (23 Pa.C.S. Domestic Relations Chapters 21-29), became effective April 25, 2011.

The nature of the changes were briefly noted in an online article entitled Open Adoption in Pennsylvania, by law student Lisa Dougan, posted on March 11, 2011, by Juris (the official blog of the Duquesne University School of Law News Magazine).

The four overall objectives of the rule changes are set forth in the notice's Recommendation:

(1) Amendments to existing rules so that the court can ensure birth parents received notice of the opportunity of birth relatives to enter into agreements with adopting parents for post-adoption contact or communication which become legally enforceable, upon court approval, and amendments to existing rules to accurately reference statements of medical and personal and/or social history information, their maintenance in the court record, and their accessibility. (See Proposed Rule 15.3(a)(8), (a)(10), (b)(2), (b)(4), (f), Proposed Rule 15.4(a)(9), (a)(11), (b)(1), (b)(3), (f), Proposed Rule 15.5(a)(9), (a)(11), (b)(2), (b)(3), (f), Proposed Rule 15.6(a)(10), (b)(3), (f), and Proposed Rule 15.8(a)(1), (b)(4)).

(2) A proposed new Rule 15.5 to address the statutory alternative procedure for confirmed consent created in Section 2504 of the Adoption Code, 23 Pa.C.S. § 2504. (See Proposed Rule 15.5).

(3) New rules implementing Act 101's provisions regarding the court's approval of voluntary post-adoption contact agreements and the procedure by which the court may modify, enforce, or discontinue such court-approved voluntary post-adoption contact agreements. (See Proposed Rules 15.7, 15.9, 15.10 and 15.11).
(4) New rules and amendments to the existing confidentiality rule to implement Act 101's provisions for releasing information in the court file, including requests for non-identifying information, identifying information and/or for contact. (See Proposed Rules 15.12, 15.13, and 15.14).
The purpose of the proposed rule changes under the Open Adoption Act is explained in the Explanatory Comment's Background section of the published notice:
Act 101 of 2010 amended the Adoption Act to provide an option for adopting parents and birth relatives to enter into legally enforceable voluntary agreements so that adopted children can have ongoing communication or contact with their birth family, if desirable. While the enforceability of voluntary post-adoption contact agreements is new, the concept of these agreements is not.
For years adopting and biological parents have recognized the benefits of post-adoption contact and have made arrangements informally. Nothing in Act 101 or these proposed rules precludes or discourages the use of such informal arrangements which have benefited children and families through the years.
However, by complying with the statute and these proposed rules, as ultimately adopted, the parties will have an agreement for post-adoption communication or contact that can be enforced by the courts, upon proper petition.
Act 101 also amended the Adoption Act to allow for the collection of a birth parent's social history in addition to personal and medical history, to permit attorneys to forward their records and information to the court for maintenance as part of the court record, and to provide new procedures for accessing information from the court record related to adoptions.

For example, Act 101 expands the class of individuals who can file a written request for non-identifying information, identifying information or contact with the court that finalized the adoption, the agency that coordinated the adoption, or the successor agency.
Finally, Act 101 provides that when there is a proper request for identifying information or contact and no authorization is on file, the entity receiving the request, including the court that finalized the adoption, shall search for the person from whom information or contact is sought, advise that person of the request, and ask that person to consent to the release of identifying information or permit contact. Searches and contact are to be provided by an authorized representative trained by the Department of Public Welfare. * * * [Reparagraphing applied]

These proposed Adoption rule changes may not be permanent. The Explanatory Comments further note the likelihood for ongoing monitoring and possible readjustment based upon forthcoming experiences by county courts:
The Committee anticipates that the experience of the local courts over the next several months working in concert with private adoption agencies, county Children and Youth Service Agencies and PAIR to implement Act 101 will provide a base of practical experience that will inform the rule-making process. In the meantime, the Committee believes that each court is aware of Act 101 and is seeking to be compliant with its requirements.
I serve as a member of the the Pennsylvania Supreme Court's Orphans' Court Procedural Rules Committee, and specifically as a member of the subcommittee that worked on the proposed rule changes with very capable staff attorneys.

Any comments on the proposed rules should be addressed in writing no later than Wednesday, August 10, 2011, to:
Lisa M. Rhode, Counsel
Orphans' Court Procedural Rules Committee
Pennsylvania Judicial Center
601 Commonwealth Avenue, Suite 6200
P.?O. Box 62635
Harrisburg PA 17106-2635

Fax: 717-231-9555
Email: orphanrules@pacourts.us 

Tuesday, June 14, 2011

Proposed Amendments of PA POA, Guardianship & Health Care Directive Laws

On June 14, 2011, the Pennsylvania Joint State Government Commission posted the latest report (June, 2011) of the Advisory Committee on Decedents' Estates Laws regarding proposed amendments to the Probate, Estates, and Fiduciaries Code (PEF Code), which is available here.

This latest report (June 2011; PDF, 85 pages) alters and updates a prior report (June 2010; PDF, 87 pages) of the same organization regarding the PEF Code.

The two reports are the product of Subcommittee study and drafting, Advisory Committee review and revision, and JSGC approval, for submission to the Pennsylvania Legislature:
Over the years, the Advisory Committee has formed various subcommittees to assist in reviewing specific topics and developing statutory recommendations involving the Probate, Estates and Fiduciaries Code for consideration by the Advisory Committee.

The Subcommittee on Guardianships and Powers of Attorney was formed to review, among other things, 20 Pa.C.S. Chapters 54 (health care), 55 (incapacitated persons) and 56 (powers of attorney).

The subcommittee consists of John F. Meck, Esq., Chair; Robert Clofine, Esq.; William R. Cooper, Esq.; The Honorable Calvin S. Drayer, Jr.; Jay C. Glickman, Esq.; Neil E. Hendershot, Esq.; The Honorable Anne E. Lazarus; John J. Lombard, Jr., Esq.; James F. Mannion, Esq.; Michael J. Mullaugh, Esq.; R. Thomas Murphy, Esq.; The Honorable Paula Francisco Ott; The Honorable Stanley R. Ott; William Campbell Ries, Esq. and Robert B. Wolf, Esq.

After reaching consensus on its legislative recommendations, the Advisory Committee presents its recommendations to the Task Force on Decedents’ Estates Laws, which is a bicameral and bipartisan panel of legislators. The Task Force authorizes the Joint State Government Commission to publish a report containing the recommendations, which serve as a basis for legislation. * * * [Paragraphs rearranged]
What is in the June 2011 Report?  Its proposed legislation would reverse one Pennsylvania Supreme Court decision (Vine, December 21, 2010) regarding financial powers of attorney, and clarify the guardianship and healthcare decision-making statutes after another Pennsylvania Supreme Court decision (D.L.H., August 17, 2011) regarding medical decision-making.
In response to the Vine [v. Commonwealth, 9 A.3d 1150 (Pa. 2010)] and [In Re] D.L.H. [2 A.3d 505 (Pa. 2010)] rulings of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, the Subcommittee on Guardianships and Powers of Attorney reviewed the topics of powers of attorney and health care decision-making and presented its recommendations at the 2011 annual meeting of the Advisory Committee.
The Advisory Committee reached consensus on the recommendations, and the Subcommittee subsequently finalized specific statutory amendments to the Probate, Estates and Fiduciaries Code, which are contained in this report.
The major statutory amendments that form the basis of this report concern the following:
(1) Third party liability and immunity regarding powers of attorney under 20 Pa.C.S.  Chapter 56, in light of the Vine ruling.
(2) An acknowledgment by the principal and affidavits of the two witnesses for powers of attorney.
(3) Health care decision-making by guardians under 20 Pa.C.S. Chapters 54 and 55, in light of the D.L.H. ruling.
Proposed legislative reversal of the Vine holding was explained in a Memo, dated April 4, 2011, from Senator Stewart J. Greenleaf to all Pennsylvania Senators:
[The Court's opinion appears to remove the immunity third parties have had for decades in relying on facially valid power of attorney.
Third parties will now be put in a position of having to investigate the circumstances surrounding the execution of a power of attorney.

Instead of routinely relying on the validity of a power of attorney, they may have to seek the principal's ratification before acting. And, in turn, if the third party questions the power of attorney and does not comply with the instructions of the attorney-in-fact, the third party could find itself subject to liability for failing to comply with an agent's instructions. * * *
The need for remedial legislation after the Vine decision was highlighted by a Pennsylvania Bar Association Recommendation, dated April 11, 2011.  That Recommendation concluded:
These amendments are vital to restore commercial viability of Powers of Attorney following the decision in Vine v. Commonwealth, 9 A.3d 1150 (Pa. 2010), while still adopting appropriate new safeguards for potentially vulnerable principals. In expressing our support for prompt action by the Pennsylvania State Legislature, we have carefully considered the proposals by the Joint State Government Commission and we support the Commission’s approach to the necessary amendments of existing statutes.
As a means of strengthening the original execution of powers of attorney in Pennsylvania, the most recent proposal would require notarization of the maker's signature and affidavits by two witnesses, which requirements parallel those of a self-proving last will.  Other amendments would allow for use of facsimile copies of documents.

The other proposal in the June 2011 Report would clarify points made in the D.L.H. case, where the PA Supreme Court considered, "[W]hether plenary guardians can refuse life-preserving medical treatment on behalf of a person who lacks -- and has always lacked -- the capacity to make personal healthcare decisions, where the person is neither suffering from an end-stage medical condition nor permanently unconscious."

Careful study of that decision revealed areas of the Guardianship statute and the Health Care Decision Making statute that should address long-term and end-of-life medical decision making by a court-appointed guardian.  The result would be these amendments:
  • § 5521. Subsection (d.1)(1) is added to provide that a guardian of the person for an incapacitated person shall have the same authority to make health care decisions on behalf of the incapacitated person as a health care representative, and a decision shall be effective without court approval, subject to (1) any limitations and conditions set forth in the order of appointment; (2) the same health care decision-making process as prescribed in the statutory provisions regarding the authority of a health care agent in making health care decisions; (3) the same limitations regarding pregnancy and regarding the duties of an attending physician and health care provider under Chapter 54; (4) the statutory provisions regarding powers and duties only granted by the court and regarding powers and duties not granted to a guardian; and (5) any other provision regarding health care representatives as set forth in Chapter 54, except the statutory provisions regarding who may act as a health care representative.
  • Subsection (d.1)(2) is added to specify that, to the extent practicable, a guardian of the person must consult with close family members of the incapacitated person in making a health care decision, particularly one involving end-of-life decision-making.
  • Subsection (d.1)(3) is added to require that a petition that is filed for the appointment of a guardian of the person on or after the effective date of the act must state whether it is proposed that the guardian of the person shall have the power to make health care decisions and, if so, whether the guardian shall have all the powers of a health care representative to make such decisions, and any limitation of those powers.
  • Subsection (d.1)(4) is added to require that the notice of a petition or hearing must contain the information under the previous paragraph.
  • Subsection (d.1)(5) is added to require that an order of appointment of a guardian of the person that is issued on or after the effective date of the act must specify whether the guardian of the person shall have the power to make health care decisions and, if so, whether the guardian shall have all the powers of a health care representative to make such decisions, and any limitation of those powers.
  • Subsection (d.1)(6) is added to specify that a guardian of the person appointed before the effective date of the act shall have the same powers as a health care representative unless (1) a prior court order has limited the power of the guardian to make health care decisions or (2) a health care representative is available and assumes authority to act by agreement between the health care representative and the guardian, in which case the guardian thereafter has no health care decision-making powers.
I serve as a Guardianship/POA Subcommittee member and as an Advisory Committee member, and I worked on the reports and recommendations.

I strongly advocate for the Legislature's adoption of the recommendations contained in the June 2010 Report, as modified by the June 2011 Report.

Update:  10/27/11:

In searching bill information on the website of the Pennsylvania General Assembly, I do not find any legislation pending that derives from the two reports.

However, a guardianship-related bill, House Bill 1720, was introduced recently and finds support.  See: PA EE&F Law Blog posting "Granny Snatching" Prohibition Pending in PA (10/25/11).

Monday, June 06, 2011

PA DoR Revised Safe Deposit Box Entry

The Pennsylvania Department of Revenue has loosened restrictions as to who may inventory a safe deposit box in which a decedent had an interest.

By its Inheritance Tax Bulletin 2011-02, entitled Safe Deposit Box Inventories and Notice, issued May 11, 2011, PA DoR announced its modification, effective on that date, of "the procedures under which estate representatives may enter the safe deposit box of a decedent" pursuant to the the provisions of the Inheritance and Estate Tax Act of 1991 (the 'Act')."

The general rule regarding entry into a safe deposit box of a decedent is stated in 93 Pa. Code § 93.11 ("Limitation of entry by statute or regulation"), as follows:
No person seeking entry otherwise prohibited by the act, having actual knowledge of the death of a decedent may enter a safe deposit box of the decedent unless the entry is made under * * * [the Act] and no person acting as deputy, agent or in a similar capacity may enter a safe deposit box except as provided in this subchapter.
Subchapter B of those Regulations specifies the parameters of access, inventory, removal of contents, and reporting of values, regarding a decedent's safe deposit box.  Those regulations address:
  • Permission to Enter a Box Without Notice to the Department ( 93.31, 93.32, 93.33, 93.34, 93.35, 93.36, & 93.37 ) where a bank, Department representative, court, or business is involved or where a last will or cemetary deed is sought;
  • Subsequent entries (93.51);
  • Confidential information (93.61); and
Approximately twenty years ago and before, only PA DoR representatives could open and inventory a safe deposit box after an owner's death. Then the Department relented, and allowed, first banks, and later attorneys or accountants, to perform an inventory at an intial post-motem opening and then report to PA DoR.

With the issuance of this latest bulletin, a personal representative need not be accompanied by a Revenue representative, a bank employee, a lawyer, or an accountant, to inventory a safe deposit box:
[N]either a department or bank employee, nor lawyer or CPA must be present at a safe deposit box inventory. Instead, pursuant to the Act, a safe deposit box of a decedent may be entered at the time fixed in a notice mailed within seven days of the date of proposed entry, to the Department of Revenue and to the financial institution in which the box is located. 72 P.S. § 9193. The department no longer will provide employees to be present at safe deposit box inventories.
The procedures for those authorized by law to access a decedent's safe deposit box remain the same:
The Act requires that notice of a proposed safe deposit box entry and inventory must be delivered to the department via United States Postal Service with return receipt service.

The Act allows that, when a person furnishes a signed statement under penalty of perjury that he or someone in his behalf has given this notice, the financial institution in which a safe deposit box of a decedent is located shall permit entry into the box and removal of its contents, without the presence of a department or bank employee.

(1) The Notice must include:
a. the name of estate and person entering the box,
b. the name and street address of the financial institution in which the box is located, and
c. the date and time of entry.

(2) The Notice must be:
a. delivered via United States Postal Service, return receipt service
b. copied to the financial institution in which the box is located
c. sent at least seven days in advance to:
PA Dept of Revenue
Safe Deposit Box Unit
P.O. Box 280601
Harrisburg, PA 17128-0601
The Department's bulletin was announced in its Tax Update, April/May 2011 (Issue No. 155), on pages 5 & 6, which provided a further explanation:
At the time of entry, the estate representative must also provide a statement to the financial institution attesting the notice was sent to the department, with the following or similar language:
Under penalties of perjury I swear that I gave the notice required under Section 2193 of the Inheritance and Estate Tax Act, 72 PS § 9193, to the Pennsylvania Department of Revenue, via United States Postal Service, of my intention to enter this safe deposit box on today’s date.
Within 20 days of entry, the estate representative must also return a completed Safe Deposit Box Inventory form, REV-485, to the department’s Safe Deposit Box Unit.
That inventory reporting form, REV-485 ("Safe Deposit Box Inventory"), revised May, 2004, is available online.

Thursday, May 19, 2011

"Conquer Catastrophe" Course on June 10, 2011

On Friday, June 10, 2011, from 9:00 AM to 4:30 PM, the Pennsylvania Bar Institute will present a course entitled "Conquer Catastrophe: Reviving Professionally and Healing Personally".  I am a course planner and a presenter.  The subject?  Recovery by lawyers from a personal catastrophe.

The PBI's website lists the course description through a Table of Contents of the course manual.  It is priced very reasonably, since this presentation is a service to the Bar.

I constructed a separate website for the course, also entitled "Conquer Catastrophe", which offers information and resources on the subject matter, but not the written materials for the course.

As a course planner, I submitted a course explanation to be included in the materials, which I reproduce below. 

This course is very unusual and highly personal, but relevant.  The presenters' backgrounds are deep and varied.  We will all learn from each other.

The course will be presented just one-time, live in the Harrisburg area, broadcast simultaneously to ten other locations in Pennsylvania, on Friday, June 10, 2011, from 9:00 AM until 4:30 PM. Of the six hours of continuing legal education, one hour will qualify for the ethics requirements.

Afterwards, the course will become available from PBI in audio format, with the printed materials; and it could be ordered online.  The companion website will remain available publicly, free.
Conquer Catastrophe:
Course Overview through Twenty Questions
By Neil E. Hendershot, Esq.
"I am not concerned that you have fallen.
I am concerned that you arise."
-- Abraham Lincoln (Lawyer & 16th US President)

          “So You're Going to Present . . .”, published in 2004 by the Association for Continuing Legal Education, is a booklet that guides legal course planners and speakers in preparing a "high quality learning-focused presentation."
          For the construction of this unusual and quite customized PBI course, I answered that booklet’s questions (Chapter 2, pp. 8-9), which reflect the purpose and setting of the course, and suggest what participants might learn:
1.  What are the issues that have given rise to dealing with this topic?
          My personal experiences and past searches for resources highlighted a lack of concentrated information targeted towards lawyers who are affected by a personal catastrophic event.  I sought guidance for such a “patient-professional” (my term for a lawyer whacked by a sudden debilitating illness, accident, or event) to revive professionally and heal personally for a continued productive life.  This course is our attempt to assemble such information.
2.  Is there a specific event or series of events that precipitated the concern about this topic?
          My personal experiences in 1999 with a burst appendix and life-saving internal surgery, and again in 2009 with a broken neck and reconstructive spinal surgery, together with recoveries from those unforeseen, catastrophic events, were my primary motivation to plan this course.  However, current national events, including the increasing number of brain and spinal injuries suffered by our troops serving in Iraq and Afghanistan, and also the shooting of Representative Gifford in Arizona, highlight the need for rehabilitation and retraining for productive lives.
3.  Are there new changes?  e.g., new legislation, regulations, or case law?
          Pennsylvania state laws regarding disability have not changed significantly, recently.  However, there are pending reports to the Legislature regarding both Powers of Attorney (Chapter 56 of the Probate, Estates & Fiduciaries Code) and Guardianship (Chapter 55).  The proposed improvements mainly affect procedures and formalities, not substantive rights.  These evolving financial and personal management arrangements will be referenced.
          Furthermore, the existing federal laws and systems providing benefits to disabled persons likely will be changing due to long-term fiscal constraints, but that is a political process only now gaining momentum.  We will reference the Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid systems.
          On the other hand, the Veterans Administration and the armed services are more receptive towards long-term treatment of brain injuries for injured military personnel.
4.  What are the new issues related to these changes that need to be addressed?
          For the patient-professional, applicable legal areas include disability insurance coverage, medical insurance coverage, government benefits, increasing accountability as a professional under malpractice insurance and ethical rules, and tort reform. 
          Also, the business and legal environments have constricted economically so that responding to recovering patient-professionals can be more difficult.
5.  How do these issues affect practice?
          A lawyer struck with an injury, illness, or traumatic event must develop a personal approach to maintain a position or a practice, even while reduced in capability.  This is a complex, demanding process.  It can be conducted successfully if the patient-professional tenaciously pursues a vision of recovery and resumption -- or at least reorientation into productive activity.
6.  Given these issues, what possible content could be focused on?
          Those topics are set forth in the course agenda.
7.  What are the areas of content that may need to be addressed through continuing education?  Are the issues being addressed in other ways as well?
          This course is distinctive and wide-ranging.  These topics are addressed by other disciplines s and in other settings than those involving lawyers.  For example, the University of Maryland’s Shock & Trauma Center and many major medical centers, hold educational seminars. Its Trauma Survivors Network provides information and support to members and their families.
          Some health care insurers offer case management and wellness programs.
          Specific causes of personal catastrophe are addressed by non-profit organizations, such as the American Heart Association (for heart and stroke), the Christopher Reeves Foundation (for spinal injuries), the American Cancer Society (for all forms of cancer), and the American Lung Association (for breathing diseases), among thousands that educate and advocate.
          Social networking collects people of similar interests, commitments, or experiences, who share resources and offer encouragement.
8.  If this is a part of several presentations, how does this presentation fit with what else is being presented?
          This is a one-time course.  However, I hope that other professions, such as accountants and physicians, might develop similar informational resources.
9.  How do other lawyers see this issue? What do they think they need to learn?  How open are they to learning and changing in this area of practice?
          This is the point of the suggested opening exercise for the audience and their sharing of stories.
10.  What is the likely range of perspectives about this issue?
          Lawyers are a hardy, highly intelligent, ego-driven, self-reliant, competitive group.  Lawyers may find the threat of disability or reduced capability difficult to consider. 
          Also, lawyers are driven by thought processes involving time management, rationality, advocacy, and judgment. These characteristics and expectations could be at odds with admissions of performance disability, lack of control, uncertainty as to outcome, extended recuperation, and dependency upon others.
          As to the views of individuals affected by a personal catastrophe, a few speakers will relay their experiences, and others’ stories can be accessed online on the website of the University of Maryland’s Shock & Trauma Center.
11.  What does this audience assume to be true about this issue?  Are these assumptions valid?
          I will ask questions about audience assumptions at the beginning of the course.  The presentations will test whether those assumptions are valid.
12.  What are the hot concerns?  Why?
          The "hottest" concerns would be lawyer performance, fulfillment of ethical obligations, and practice maintenance.  Those are survival issues.  Other issues may seem less immediate, but must be addressed long-term for resumption of a legal practice and emotional stability.  However, all elements are intertwined.
13.  What is the nature of the skill or knowledge gap for this audience in relation to this aspect of the law or legal practice?
          The knowledge and skills required to address recovery from a personal catastrophe are not taught in law school and are not developed in professional work except by observation.  Lawyers are trained in problem-solving and in advocacy instead.  These abilities can be applied to personal situations and challenges.  Lawyers can acquire the skills and knowledge to accomplish a revived work role and healthy personal life.  Much knowledge, however, derives from other fields, such as healthcare systems, psychology/psychiatry, neuroscience and other medical specialties, physical therapy, and even religion/spirituality.  This is the knowledge gap we address in this course.
14.  What is the cause of the gap?
          Limited personal experience, specialization in the law, unpredictability as to a particular future situation, avoidance of negative thinking, focus on day-to-day demands, and a presumption that “it will not happen to me”.
15.  What is the impact of the gap in knowledge or skill on individual practitioners and their clients?
          The gap in knowledge, together with the imposition of disability or debilitation, can result in failure by an attorney to fulfill basic professional and office requirements.  Such insufficiencies can result in lost clients, missed deadlines, insufficient efforts, minimal revenue, personal hopelessness, long-term depression, altered reputation, and possible malpractice, even disbarment.
16.  What are the likely similarities and differences between me and this audience in relation to my view of the topic, my knowledge, skill, and experience?
          My view evolved through two experiences.  I faced challenges to “conquer catastrophe” by being injured by illness in 1999 and by accident in 2009.  I worked through recoveries, with mixed effectiveness.  Those in the audience may not have experienced such catastrophes, or may have coped better or worse than me.  Some may face debilitating illnesses that may prevent return to prior functioning, and some may face degenerative diseases that constantly redefine functioning at a lower level. My views developed in conjunction with the reactions of family, co-workers, and friends.
17.  Will this topic likely appeal to general practitioners, or to lawyers who specialize in this practice area?
          This is not a course for lawyers to develop a proficiency in professional catastrophe remediation -- that field already is known as "personal injury" or “medical malpractice” law.  Instead, this course is intended to inform and guide a lawyer, or that lawyer's family, co-workers, or friends, in constructively and progressively addressing a personal catastrophic event, so that the lawyer can revive a legal practice/position, and heal personally.
18.  What will the audience be doing before and after my presentation?
          Likely, go right back into their current circumstances – normal work, personal recovery, interpersonal support of another, or provider services.  I hope that each participant will be more knowledgeable and positive about the processes and adjustments following a personal catastrophe.
19.  How large is this audience likely to be?
          As large as it needs to be, for those who have been affected.  Others, who now are oblivious to the offering of this course, will access it in the future when a personal catastrophe occurs.
20.  What is the facility like?  What limitations does it have in relation to my being seen and heard by the audience?  What audio and visual equipment is available?
           This is a live presentation at PBI’s headquarters in the Harrisburg area.  This course will be conducted one-time, simultaneously broadcast by audio/video to remote locations in Pennsylvania, and recorded for future audio replay, perhaps over the Internet.